Index of Rationality

Index of Rationality 2Printed version of the publication is here: Index of Rationality 1 and 2 The Index of Rationality for the second group of products (second quarterly report) was developed by means of comparing purchase prices paid for medical disposables used in the health care sector. In order to provide a better overview of the state of affairs in this sector, the Index was developed for six types of products, those being:- transfusion kits;- infusion kits;- syringes;- cotton wads;- cotton patches; and- calico bandages. These products were selected because they are considered to be the most frequently used disposables by all health care centres, hospitals and clinics. The ultimate goal was to determine whether unified prices were obtained from the suppliers or there are price deviations, given the fact that these materials are used on day-to-day basis and are therefore frequently purchased. Information related to prices paid were obtained by means of Freedom of Information (FOI) applications, submitted to all contracting authorities in the health care sector and registered in the Electronic Public Procurement System (EPPS).

Index of Rationality 2Printed version of the publication is here: Index of Rationality 1 and 2 The Index of Rationality for the second group of products (second quarterly report) was developed by means of comparing purchase prices paid for medical disposables used in the health care sector. In order to provide a better overview of the state of affairs in this sector, the Index was developed for six types of products, those being:- transfusion kits;- infusion kits;- syringes;- cotton wads;- cotton patches; and- calico bandages. These products were selected because they are considered to be the most frequently used disposables by all health care centres, hospitals and clinics. The ultimate goal was to determine whether unified prices were obtained from the suppliers or there are price deviations, given the fact that these materials are used on day-to-day basis and are therefore frequently purchased. Information related to prices paid were obtained by means of Freedom of Information (FOI) applications, submitted to all contracting authorities in the health care sector and registered in the Electronic Public Procurement System (EPPS).

Index of Rationality 2Printed version of the publication is here: Index of Rationality 1 and 2 The Index of Rationality for the second group of products (second quarterly report) was developed by means of comparing purchase prices paid for medical disposables used in the health care sector. In order to provide a better overview of the state of affairs in this sector, the Index was developed for six types of products, those being:- transfusion kits;- infusion kits;- syringes;- cotton wads;- cotton patches; and- calico bandages. These products were selected because they are considered to be the most frequently used disposables by all health care centres, hospitals and clinics. The ultimate goal was to determine whether unified prices were obtained from the suppliers or there are price deviations, given the fact that these materials are used on day-to-day basis and are therefore frequently purchased. Information related to prices paid were obtained by means of Freedom of Information (FOI) applications, submitted to all contracting authorities in the health care sector and registered in the Electronic Public Procurement System (EPPS).

Index of Rationality 1 GENERAL CONCLUSION This is the first Cost-Effectiveness Index calculated for Macedonia and is designed as an instrument for state institutions to improve cost-effectiveness of public procurements, i.e., public spending. As part of the first analysis, the Cost-Effectiveness Index was calculated for five types of procurements. The individual indices per procurement type show significant differences in terms of the value, i.e., the price paid by different state institutions for the products and services targeted by the present index. The lowest and highest price ratio for effective hour of winter maintenance is 1:2.5, for 1 ton of industrial salt – 1:5.5, for 1 ream of standard copy paper – 1:2, for discounts of fuel oil EL-1 – 1:4, and for contracts for New Year decorations – 1:30. In that, one should take into account the fact that in most cases analysed lower prices were not attained for procurement of larger quantities, which is contrary to any economic logic. This indicates that state institutions must make serious efforts for cost-effective public spending. Apart from price differences, the analysis also shows major discrepancies in the terms and conditions under which state institutions implement procurements for same type of products and services. With this in mind, the state institutions should pursue thorough market research prior to announcing the calls and should pursue the procurement approach that will ensure more frugal public spending.

Index of Rationality 1 GENERAL CONCLUSION This is the first Cost-Effectiveness Index calculated for Macedonia and is designed as an instrument for state institutions to improve cost-effectiveness of public procurements, i.e., public spending. As part of the first analysis, the Cost-Effectiveness Index was calculated for five types of procurements. The individual indices per procurement type show significant differences in terms of the value, i.e., the price paid by different state institutions for the products and services targeted by the present index. The lowest and highest price ratio for effective hour of winter maintenance is 1:2.5, for 1 ton of industrial salt – 1:5.5, for 1 ream of standard copy paper – 1:2, for discounts of fuel oil EL-1 – 1:4, and for contracts for New Year decorations – 1:30. In that, one should take into account the fact that in most cases analysed lower prices were not attained for procurement of larger quantities, which is contrary to any economic logic. This indicates that state institutions must make serious efforts for cost-effective public spending. Apart from price differences, the analysis also shows major discrepancies in the terms and conditions under which state institutions implement procurements for same type of products and services. With this in mind, the state institutions should pursue thorough market research prior to announcing the calls and should pursue the procurement approach that will ensure more frugal public spending.

Index of Rationality 1 GENERAL CONCLUSION This is the first Cost-Effectiveness Index calculated for Macedonia and is designed as an instrument for state institutions to improve cost-effectiveness of public procurements, i.e., public spending. As part of the first analysis, the Cost-Effectiveness Index was calculated for five types of procurements. The individual indices per procurement type show significant differences in terms of the value, i.e., the price paid by different state institutions for the products and services targeted by the present index. The lowest and highest price ratio for effective hour of winter maintenance is 1:2.5, for 1 ton of industrial salt – 1:5.5, for 1 ream of standard copy paper – 1:2, for discounts of fuel oil EL-1 – 1:4, and for contracts for New Year decorations – 1:30. In that, one should take into account the fact that in most cases analysed lower prices were not attained for procurement of larger quantities, which is contrary to any economic logic. This indicates that state institutions must make serious efforts for cost-effective public spending. Apart from price differences, the analysis also shows major discrepancies in the terms and conditions under which state institutions implement procurements for same type of products and services. With this in mind, the state institutions should pursue thorough market research prior to announcing the calls and should pursue the procurement approach that will ensure more frugal public spending.

Index of Rationality 1 GENERAL CONCLUSION This is the first Cost-Effectiveness Index calculated for Macedonia and is designed as an instrument for state institutions to improve cost-effectiveness of public procurements, i.e., public spending. As part of the first analysis, the Cost-Effectiveness Index was calculated for five types of procurements. The individual indices per procurement type show significant differences in terms of the value, i.e., the price paid by different state institutions for the products and services targeted by the present index. The lowest and highest price ratio for effective hour of winter maintenance is 1:2.5, for 1 ton of industrial salt – 1:5.5, for 1 ream of standard copy paper – 1:2, for discounts of fuel oil EL-1 – 1:4, and for contracts for New Year decorations – 1:30. In that, one should take into account the fact that in most cases analysed lower prices were not attained for procurement of larger quantities, which is contrary to any economic logic. This indicates that state institutions must make serious efforts for cost-effective public spending. Apart from price differences, the analysis also shows major discrepancies in the terms and conditions under which state institutions implement procurements for same type of products and services. With this in mind, the state institutions should pursue thorough market research prior to announcing the calls and should pursue the procurement approach that will ensure more frugal public spending.

Index of Rationality 1 GENERAL CONCLUSION This is the first Cost-Effectiveness Index calculated for Macedonia and is designed as an instrument for state institutions to improve cost-effectiveness of public procurements, i.e., public spending. As part of the first analysis, the Cost-Effectiveness Index was calculated for five types of procurements. The individual indices per procurement type show significant differences in terms of the value, i.e., the price paid by different state institutions for the products and services targeted by the present index. The lowest and highest price ratio for effective hour of winter maintenance is 1:2.5, for 1 ton of industrial salt – 1:5.5, for 1 ream of standard copy paper – 1:2, for discounts of fuel oil EL-1 – 1:4, and for contracts for New Year decorations – 1:30. In that, one should take into account the fact that in most cases analysed lower prices were not attained for procurement of larger quantities, which is contrary to any economic logic. This indicates that state institutions must make serious efforts for cost-effective public spending. Apart from price differences, the analysis also shows major discrepancies in the terms and conditions under which state institutions implement procurements for same type of products and services. With this in mind, the state institutions should pursue thorough market research prior to announcing the calls and should pursue the procurement approach that will ensure more frugal public spending.

Index of Rationality 1 GENERAL CONCLUSION This is the first Cost-Effectiveness Index calculated for Macedonia and is designed as an instrument for state institutions to improve cost-effectiveness of public procurements, i.e., public spending. As part of the first analysis, the Cost-Effectiveness Index was calculated for five types of procurements. The individual indices per procurement type show significant differences in terms of the value, i.e., the price paid by different state institutions for the products and services targeted by the present index. The lowest and highest price ratio for effective hour of winter maintenance is 1:2.5, for 1 ton of industrial salt – 1:5.5, for 1 ream of standard copy paper – 1:2, for discounts of fuel oil EL-1 – 1:4, and for contracts for New Year decorations – 1:30. In that, one should take into account the fact that in most cases analysed lower prices were not attained for procurement of larger quantities, which is contrary to any economic logic. This indicates that state institutions must make serious efforts for cost-effective public spending. Apart from price differences, the analysis also shows major discrepancies in the terms and conditions under which state institutions implement procurements for same type of products and services. With this in mind, the state institutions should pursue thorough market research prior to announcing the calls and should pursue the procurement approach that will ensure more frugal public spending.

Index of Rationality 1 GENERAL CONCLUSION This is the first Cost-Effectiveness Index calculated for Macedonia and is designed as an instrument for state institutions to improve cost-effectiveness of public procurements, i.e., public spending. As part of the first analysis, the Cost-Effectiveness Index was calculated for five types of procurements. The individual indices per procurement type show significant differences in terms of the value, i.e., the price paid by different state institutions for the products and services targeted by the present index. The lowest and highest price ratio for effective hour of winter maintenance is 1:2.5, for 1 ton of industrial salt – 1:5.5, for 1 ream of standard copy paper – 1:2, for discounts of fuel oil EL-1 – 1:4, and for contracts for New Year decorations – 1:30. In that, one should take into account the fact that in most cases analysed lower prices were not attained for procurement of larger quantities, which is contrary to any economic logic. This indicates that state institutions must make serious efforts for cost-effective public spending. Apart from price differences, the analysis also shows major discrepancies in the terms and conditions under which state institutions implement procurements for same type of products and services. With this in mind, the state institutions should pursue thorough market research prior to announcing the calls and should pursue the procurement approach that will ensure more frugal public spending.

Index of Rationality 1 GENERAL CONCLUSION This is the first Cost-Effectiveness Index calculated for Macedonia and is designed as an instrument for state institutions to improve cost-effectiveness of public procurements, i.e., public spending. As part of the first analysis, the Cost-Effectiveness Index was calculated for five types of procurements. The individual indices per procurement type show significant differences in terms of the value, i.e., the price paid by different state institutions for the products and services targeted by the present index. The lowest and highest price ratio for effective hour of winter maintenance is 1:2.5, for 1 ton of industrial salt – 1:5.5, for 1 ream of standard copy paper – 1:2, for discounts of fuel oil EL-1 – 1:4, and for contracts for New Year decorations – 1:30. In that, one should take into account the fact that in most cases analysed lower prices were not attained for procurement of larger quantities, which is contrary to any economic logic. This indicates that state institutions must make serious efforts for cost-effective public spending. Apart from price differences, the analysis also shows major discrepancies in the terms and conditions under which state institutions implement procurements for same type of products and services. With this in mind, the state institutions should pursue thorough market research prior to announcing the calls and should pursue the procurement approach that will ensure more frugal public spending.